Before a Homeowner Ever Decides to Sell on Their Own, There’s a Story Behind it
Why FSBOs Are Still Worth Your Time
“For Sale by Owner” listings make up a small portion of today’s market — less than 7% of all home sales according to the National Association of Realtors — but they represent an opportunity-rich niche for agents who know how to approach them the right way.
Most FSBO sellers aren’t avoiding agents out of dislike; they simply think they’ll save money or can handle the process alone. But when you show them that hiring you adds value, not cost, everything changes.
Step 1: Shift Your Approach from Pitch to Partnership
The fastest way to turn a FSBO conversation around is to stop “selling” and start helping.
Instead of, “I’d love to list your home,”
try, “I completely understand wanting to try it on your own — many homeowners start that way. If you ever want a quick pricing analysis or help reviewing your buyer’s offer, I’m happy to help.”
You’ve just positioned yourself as a resource instead of a rival.
Step 2: Use Curiosity-Based Questions to Build Trust
When reaching out by phone or at the door, lead with empathy and curiosity.
Example Script:
“Hi [Name], I noticed you’re selling your home yourself — it looks great! I’m just curious, what made you decide to go the FSBO route?”
Their answer tells you everything you need to know. Are they trying to save money? Avoid pressure? Move fast? Each reason becomes your path in.
Follow-Up Script:
“That makes sense — a lot of owners start there. If you’d ever like a free local market snapshot or a few tips on increasing your visibility, I’d be glad to share those.”
You’ve planted a seed of trust — and curiosity about what you know that they don’t.
Step 3: Offer Value That Eases Their Frustrations
Most FSBO sellers quickly discover three pain points:
-
Limited exposure — their listing isn’t reaching enough qualified buyers.
-
Pricing confusion — they’re unsure how to price competitively without undercutting themselves.
-
Paperwork overwhelm — legal forms, disclosures, and negotiations feel daunting.
Use these frustrations to demonstrate your value with helpful, low-pressure offers:
-
Provide a free home valuation or FSBO success checklist.
-
Share a market update postcard showing local activity and price trends.
-
Offer a contract review session or open house checklist.
Each step keeps you visible as the expert who helps, not sells.
Step 4: Stay Present with Gentle Follow-Up
Consistency builds familiarity — and familiarity builds trust.
Create a simple follow-up rhythm:
-
Week 1: A quick “hope it’s going well” text with a helpful tip.
-
Week 2: Drop a FSBO postcard highlighting a success story or useful stat.
-
Week 3: Call or email offering free feedback on their photos or pricing.
Many FSBOs hire an agent within 30 days after listing — often the one who’s been most helpful.
Step 5: When They’re Ready, Make the Transition Easy
When they reach the point of frustration, they’ll remember who guided them — you.
Transition Script:
“You’ve done a great job getting this far. If you’d like, I can step in and handle the marketing, showings, and negotiations from here — that way you can focus on your move and still get the best price possible.”
You’re not taking over — you’re taking the stress off.
The Takeaway
The secret to FSBO conversion isn’t pressure — it’s patience, presence, and value.
When you show up consistently with empathy and expertise, you stop being “another agent” and start being their solution.
Helpful Tool: FSBO Postcard Series
Stay top-of-mind with our FSBO postcard series — designed to educate and build trust with sellers who are trying to go it alone.
Each postcard delivers helpful, non-salesy tips that keep you positioned as the professional they’ll call when they’re ready for help.
👉 View the FSBO Postcard Series →
PLUS: When you have time…below are some marketing tools to help support your success.
2. The Free 2025 Q4 Real Estate Marketing Guide
Kickstart 2025 with our Quarterly Real Estate Marketing Guide to help you achieve your real estate business goals. Packed with tools like a goal-setting sheet, monthly insights, tailored task lists, and marketing recommendations, this free guide is your ultimate resource for success—download it today for FREE! – Click Here
The Free Interactive 6-Month Real Estate Business Plan allows you to enter your business goals for the remainder of the year and get a breakdown of how many prospects, listings, closings, and so on are needed to reach your goals. – Click Here
