How to Move Winter Fence-Sitters Forward (Without Pressure or Pushing)
Winter creates a unique kind of seller mindset. Homeowners aren’t inactive—they’re observant. They’re watching the market, noticing headlines, and quietly deciding who they’ll trust when the timing feels right.
These are winter fence-sitters, and how you show up now directly impacts who they call later.
Understand What Winter Fence-Sitters Are Really Thinking
Most fence-sitters aren’t saying “no.” They’re saying “not yet.” Their hesitation usually comes from uncertainty—pricing, timing, or fear of making the wrong move.
Your role isn’t to persuade; it’s to reduce uncertainty through calm, helpful communication.
Lead With Education, Not Urgency
Winter is the perfect season for educational marketing. Market updates, home value checkups, and short reports help homeowners feel informed without feeling pressured.
When you consistently answer the questions they’re already asking, you become the obvious next call.
Messaging idea:
-
“Curious how winter sales compare to spring?”
-
“Here’s what today’s buyers are paying attention to right now.”
-
“Thinking about selling later this year? Here’s what to know now.”
Consistency Builds Trust While Others Pause
Many agents go quiet in winter. Staying visible—without being salesy—creates contrast. A monthly postcard, newsletter, or scheduled campaign reassures fence-sitters that you’re steady, prepared, and paying attention to the market year-round.
Example touchpoints:
-
Market Update Postcards
-
Community Newsletters
-
Home Value Reports
Invite Conversation, Don’t Force Decisions
Your winter marketing should open doors, not close them. Soft calls-to-action like “Let’s talk when you’re ready” or “Happy to share insights anytime” keep the relationship comfortable and ongoing.
Messaging idea:
-
“No rush—just here as a resource.”
-
“Planning ahead starts with good information.”
Fence-sitters don’t move because they’re pushed. They move because they feel confident. When spring arrives, the agent who consistently educated, reassured, and stayed present is the one they trust.
Launch a Geographic Farm Scheduled Campaign and stay in front of your market throughout 2026 without effort, Here →
______________________________________________________________________
PLUS: When you have time…below are some marketing tools to help support your success.
2. The Free 2026 Q1 Real Estate Marketing Guide
Kickstart 2026 with our Quarterly Real Estate Marketing Guide to help you achieve your real estate business goals. Packed with tools like a goal-setting sheet, monthly insights, tailored task lists, and marketing recommendations, this free guide is your ultimate resource for success—download it today for FREE! – Click Here
The Free Interactive 6-Month Real Estate Business Plan allows you to enter your business goals for the remainder of the year and get a breakdown of how many prospects, listings, closings, and so on are needed to reach your goals. – Click Here
